Returning Individual Research Results and Data: Digging Deeper into Genetic Results and Secondary Findings

Webinar

Presented on: September 21, 2023

Presented at: Virtual

The MRCT Center released a series of case studies describing research stakeholder experiences of returning individual results to participants at a recent webinar in May.  Given the interest and number of questions we received, we offered three virtual “Digging Deeper” sessions to foster additional discussion and learning about topics that can be challenging to navigate. 

This webinar was the third of the three webinars in the Digging Deeper series. Megan Frone of the National Cancer Institute discussed a case about returning genetic/genomic results and secondary findings.

Returning Individual Research Results & Data: Digging Deeper into Genetic Testing Secondary Findings webinar recording

Related Resources

ACMG/AMP Recommendations for Return of Secondary Findings
NASEM Returning Individual Research Results to Participants

Case Study: Responsibly Returning Secondary Findings
May 2, 2023 webinar: Returning Individual Research Results and Data to Participants
July 27, 2023 webinar: Digging Deeper into Pfizer’s Patient Data Return Solution
August 17, 2023: Digging Deeper into IRB/HRPP Responsibilities
Return of Individual Results website

Defining “recklessness” in research misconduct proceedings

Publication

Published on: September 5, 2023

Published in: Accountability in Research

Mark Barnes, co-faculty director of the MRCT Center and Partner at Ropes & Gray, colleagues Minal Caron and Sarah Dohan at Ropes & Gray, and Barbara Bierer addressed the definition of “recklessness” in research misconduct proceedings, reviewing its history and application, and proposing a framework and factors to consider in recklessness determinations.

Returning Individual Research Results and Data: Digging Deeper Webinar Series

Webinar Series

Presented on: July 27, August 17 and September 21, 2023

The MRCT Center released a series of case studies describing research stakeholder experiences of returning individual results to participants at a recent webinar.  Given the interest and number of questions we received, we offered three virtual “Digging Deeper” sessions to foster additional discussion and learning about topics that can be challenging to navigate.  

Returning of Individual Research Results and Data: Digging Deeper into IRB/HRPP Responsibilities

Webinar

Presented on: August 17, 2023

Presented at: Virtual

Related Resources

Case Study: IRB/HRPP Responsibilities
May 2, 2023 webinar: Returning Individual Research Results and Data to Participants
July 27, 2023 webinar: Digging Deeper into Pfizer’s Patient Data Return Solution
Return of Individual Results website

Review of diversity, equity, and inclusion by ethics committees: A Delphi consensus statement

Publication

Published on: August 11, 2023

Published in: Med (Cell Press)

Description: Laura Meloney, Hayat Ahmed, and Barbara Bierer coordinated a modified Delphi process to establish consensus on recommendations for IRBs/ethics committees and institutions to promote diversity and inclusion in interventional clinical research. In this paper, they discuss the 25 consolidated recommendations across four themes.

Decentralized Clinical Trials for Drugs, Biological Products, and Devices: Draft Guidance for Industry, Investigators, and Other Stakeholders

Public Comments

Presented on: July 31, 2023

Details: The MRCT Center offered comprehensive comments in response to the FDA Draft Guidance FDA-2022-D-2870, entitled Decentralized Clinical Trials for Drugs, Biological Products, and Devices: Draft Guidance for Industry, Investigators, and Other Stakeholders (FDA-2022-D-2870). The MRCT Center applauds the FDA for providing this timely and informative guidance, and our comments are intended to further clarify and expand the Agency’s recommendations. Read more here.

Terms and conditions apply: an ethical analysis of mobile health user agreements in research

Publication

Published on: July 14, 2023

Published in: Journal of Law and the Biosciences

Description: Luke Gelinas, MRCT Center Senior Advisor, Walker Morrell, former MRCT Center Project Manager, and Barbara Bierer published an ethical analysis of terms of service and other agreements used in mobile health technologies in clinical research. Risks, mitigating strategies, and recommendations for disclosure (with points to consider) were discussed to help ensure the privacy interests and rights of participants.

Site staff perspectives on communicating trial results to participants: Cost and feasibility results from the Show RESPECT cluster randomized, factorial, mixed-methods trial

Publication

Published on: July 29, 2023

Published in: The Society for Clinical Trials

Description: Colleagues in the UK, assisted by Dr. Bierer, assessed site staff experience in returning plain language summaries to participants after completion of a trial. Not only did the staff feel that the communication was important but there were no concerns or challenges in responding to participant questions. Operations and cost were both feasible.